On The Ganga Mail: Lessons From Bleeding Bombay

Lessons From Bleeding Bombay
Tuesday, July 11, 2006

I have never been to Bombay. I have been there only once, to attend the launch of a Yana Gupta calendar, but since the stay lasted exactly 24 hours, I don't count it as a stay. Still in those 24 hours, I packed in as much as I could.

Immediately after I landed in the afternoon, I went to the Juhu Chowpatty. I instantly recognised it! -- so many memorable songs have been shot there, including Humko tumse ho gaya hai pyaar kya karen (Amar Akbar Anthony) and Koi ladki mujhe kal raat sapne mein mili thhi (Seeta Aur Geeta). The night was calendar launch -- the kind of party you see in movies.

The next morning I wanted to visit a friend in Cuffe Parade. My hotel was in Juhu. He told me that the most convenient thing to do would be to take a autorickshaw to the Bandra station and take a local train. I went to the Bandra station, bought a Rs 7 ticket and waited for the train. The train arrived. It was so packed that I did not have the nerve to get in: I mean it was physically impossible to get in! I sadly walked away: the images of Amol Palekar and Tina Munim romancing in Baaton Baaton Mein kept flashing in my mind. The train to me was like a long-lost girlfriend who I could recognise instantly but she had disappeared even before I could call out her name.

Outside the Bandra station, I walked up to a man who I had known for 25 years -- the good, old Bombay taxiwallah! Dozens of heroes -- and dozens of times -- have sought his help to chase the heroine or the villain or to simply go to work. He put the metre down and we set off. On the way, we crossed a stretch which I had known for -- once again -- 25 years! The Marine Drive.

That's the thing about Bombay: you don't have to go to the city to see it. Those into Hindi movies have grown up in it without even setting foot on it. That's why it hurts even a Bihari or a Bengali when tragedy strikes far-off Bombay. It is the surrogate hometown of every Hindi movie-watcher.

God knows how many Amol Palekars and Tina Munims must have been travelling on the local trains, engaged in homeward journey romance, when the blasts ripped through them this evening. While I write this, the toll is 135. It is bound to go up.

The dead died an undignified and cruel death. The families are mourning them. The wounded are lying in hospitals in bloodied clothes. And the rest of the country is watching in shock. The word 'shock' is actually an exaggeration here: it should be reserved only for people who are directly linked to the tragedy -- parents whose son is still missing, wife who lost her husband, and so on. A tragedy, no matter how morbid, never chills your bone till you are actually connected to it.

As I watched the news of the blasts on TV, my heart went out to people living in far-flung areas of India who have a relative or relatives in Bombay. Phone-lines are jammed: there is no way they can get to know if their people are safe. So they are posting messages on TV channels, saying things like: "Vishal, are you OK? Please call me at 98-whatever. We are worried." The anxiety would make relatives die a hundred deaths before they can establish contact with their near and dear ones in Bombay. And there are bound to be hundreds of people who won't be forunate enough to say: "Ah, I have finally got through to him (or her)!" They might have to search through mangled bodies. What a disturbing thought!

But what was more disturbing to me, as I sat watching TV, was the fact that these channels, while flashing messages of anxious relatives, were also hosting gasbags who connected the blasts to possible derailment of Indo-Pak ties and held forth on how India should eliminate terrorism (and terrorists) and so on. I don't know whether to blame the channels or the gasbags who, unfortunately, belong to my fraternity.

Bombaywallah's don't need lecturing, they need assurance. Maybe they don't need the assurance as well, for the city is known to bounce back after every tragedy. But I find it in bad taste to give the blasts a political or a foreign affairs angle. If anyone needs lecturing, it is the police, which failed to react swiftly to the blasts. It was left to Bombaywallahs to cart fellow citizens to the hospitals: and they did that with great efficiency.

Now there is bound to be a great deal of talk on terrorism. The Bombay blasts will merely become a part of chronology. But does anybody really care to look at what actually precipitates terrorism? Nobody is a born terrorist. And one man's terrorist can be another man's freedom fighter. Every terrorist has a cause, and unless you look into the cause, you cannot finish terrorism. If you kill one terrorist, seven other will be born. That is why West Asia will never be peaceful. India too will never be 100 percent peaceful unless Kashmiris are allowed their dignity and a say in deciding their own future.

For that matter, America is never ever going to feel safe again: in the name of fighting terrorism the superpower carried out the worst kind of terrorism, as a result of which the son of every Iraqi killed by US planes must have pledged to take revenge someday. And they will succeed someday because of one simple reason: the US soldier indulges in the act of terrorism merely on the orders of the politician -- he values his own life at the same time, while the potential terrorist is guided either by passion or deep sense of personal revenge and does not care about giving up his life. And once you stop caring whether you live or die, you can do anything. Any damn thing.Why, 9/11 is an example: a bunch of determined men crushed both the balls of America, the economic superpower.

India should learn from 9/11 before it loses too many people. Nothing, after all, is worth bloodied bodies.

posted by Bishwanath Ghosh @ 10:13 PM,

37 Comments:

At 2:48 AM, Anu Russell said...: I am yet to read this current post of yours...will comment on it soon! But about tagging...I have written something in my blog and I am tagging you along to do the same...
At 3:06 AM, Anu Russell said...: There can be no reason or rhyme for such blasphemous acts. Only a person beyond his right sense of mind and thought process can indulge in doing something so vile...What did these innocent people who became martyrs today do personally to yuo that gave somebody the right to take their lives off...

This is very sad and shows that human beings are fully capable and equipped to destroy themselves...It's a shame!

Sometimes it makes me wonder if the entire political systerm knew about the impending danger that they stayed away the dangerous zones to save their souls! The B!@#$$%S.
At 5:50 PM, ravi said...: This post has been removed by a blog administrator.
At 5:51 PM, ravi said...: This post has been removed by a blog administrator.
At 3:30 AM, Arundhati said...: I don't think there can be any justification of this cowardly act. I do agree that killing the terrorists will just breed more of them and that we have to address the root issue.

But then what if the root issues themselves are questionable? I wonder if we as human beings are programmed to destroy each other and the earth...
At 9:17 PM, bongo said...: While I cannot agree with all the points in your article (the last bit actually), it is excellently written.

The ode to Bombay through the lens of Hindi movies is moving. Even though I have lived there for two years, Bombay has the same romantic connections in my mind.
At 11:47 PM, Megha Bansal said...: I have never been to Bombay, but i know it's the second most important
city in India, Delhi being the first.
Somehow I feel you are justifying terrorism...I agree that one man's
terrorist is another man's freedom fighter...BUT terror is not a
solution to anything...
how can this be justtified? how can u only say that police messed
up...why did this happen?...and isnt there the possibility of Pak being involved in it? isnt it possible that politicians themselves did it?...
...and tend to think likewise...what if this was a vote bank issue....
At 1:47 PM, Anonymous said...: what about 'rim jhim ghire sawan?'

mebe
http://mostexcitingblogever.blogspot.com/
At 5:27 AM, Cat said...: best
At 5:29 AM, Cruise said...: best
At 5:30 AM, Lindsay Lohan said...: best
At 5:31 AM, Lingeries said...: best
At 1:09 PM, wowgold said...: wow gold
At 5:31 PM, viagra said...: Informative details on history of viagra confirm that the anti-impotency drug Viagra was actually developed by researchers with the purpose of curing angina but incidentally during clinical trails, the drug was found effective in treating erectile dysfunction in men. With clinical results demonstrating the powerful effects of Viagra in triggering off erections necessary for sexual intercourse,impotency afflicted worldwide opted for the medication and the viagra phenomenon also offered suitable assistance to them in countering erectile dysfunction. Slowly and gradually Viagra has developed a deepest level of relationship with men which has further led to an indelible association between viagra and sexuality. And right now viagra and erectile dysfunction related tidbits are popular throughout the world and erectile dysfunction afflicted men worldwide are administering Viagra under medical supervision.
At 8:53 PM, Anonymous said...: Indulge yourself and find partners for hot Sexual Encounters and Adult Dating at Adult friend finder free dating site!
If you are looking for a one night stand or a casual encounter, then the Adult Swingers Club is where the game is played.
If you practice a different range of sexual and sensual activities then adult personals has the Club for you.
Download over 2000 adult dvd movies, available formats: windows, mpeg, psp and ipod!
Shop for Adult Toys, DVDs and Lingerie and other Erotic Adult Products at adult sex toys shop and adult toys store.
At 3:20 PM, Kleidung Klamotten said...: Thanks for very interesting article. btw. I really enjoyed reading all of your postsabout Klamotten . It's interesting to read ideas about your stuff and Kleidung , and observations from someone else's point of view… makes you think more. Read more about Pattern and Crochet

Visit my Bodybuilding Muskelaufbau Shop . Best regards! Schwule - Gays
At 1:38 PM, Arginin said...: Plastikkarten Kartendrucker Plastikkarten Kartendrucker Plastikkarten Kartendrucker Plastikkarten Kartendrucker Plastikkarten Kartendrucker Plastikkarten Kartendrucker Plastikkarten Kartendrucker Plastikkarten Kartendrucker Arbeitsspeicher Arbeitsspeicher Arbeitsspeicher Arbeitsspeicher Arbeitsspeicher Arbeitsspeicher Arbeitsspeicher Arbeitsspeicher Arbeitsspeicher Arbeitsspeicher Arbeitsspeicher Arbeitsspeicher Arbeitsspeicher Arbeitsspeicher Arbeitsspeicher Arbeitsspeicher
At 4:35 PM, Anonymous said...: Generic Viagra
Online Generic Viagra
buy generic viagra cialis
Buy generic viagra cialis propecia
Buy generic cialis tadalafil
Generic cialis
Tadalafil
Buy generic viagra sildenafil
Generic viagra
Sildenafil
Propecia
Finasteride
Vardenafil
generic levitra
Buy generic levitra
At 7:33 PM, Anonymous said...: Generic Viagra
Online Generic Viagra
buy generic viagra cialis
Buy generic viagra cialis propecia
Buy generic cialis tadalafil
Generic cialis
Tadalafil
Buy generic viagra sildenafil
Generic viagra
Sildenafil
Propecia
Finasteride
Vardenafil
generic levitra
Buy generic levitra
At 4:13 AM, viagra online said...: Cool web...

rx pharmacy
buy viagra
At 2:54 AM, Emily D. said...: Our Online Pharmacy no Prescription doctors will evaluate your health information and provide you with a prescription, so you do not need a prescription from your regular family physician to cheap Generic Viagra. More info at: http://www.safemeds.com/
At 2:33 AM, Julia F. said...: Nothing can be easier for you than to Order Viagra online. Well, if you suffer from erectile dysfunction syndrome (EDS) also known as impotence. The solution to your ailment is not hard to find and it is not very far away in many respects. More Info at: http://www.xlpharmacy.com
At 12:35 PM, Anonymous said...: Only a person beyond his right
viagra professional
phentrimine
vpxl
buy tamiflu
propecia online
female cialis
Buy soma
At 10:58 AM, seller said...: цукг good
At 4:51 PM, Anonymous said...: Some online poker site that free poker cash no id verification have free roll sponsorship, World bigger tours where you don't need to make any deposit to your poker account.
No deposit poker sponsorship, free 50 dollars for online poker. After you have signed up party poker account need to play game.
Bonuses for poker no deposit needed Free $50 for start playing omaha holdem and additional fifty dollars.
Free money mail bonuses for start play game of life with cards in your hand. You can also choose deposit bonus password.
Find hottest bankroll in whole internet and instant bonuses, free poker cash no id verification still avaliable to us players, going into down and up.
Game poker free bonuses no deposit required from poker sites. Free poker money no quiz
Enjoy freeb smart poker bonuses poker online at Party Poker. Promotions, the most exclusive bonus guide. Play time at online poker rooms, find the best Promo.
no deposit bonuses free money
poker cash no deposit
At 4:52 PM, Anonymous said...: Poker Party, Vulcan, Pkr, Mansion, bez depozytu, William Hill, kapitał startowy, Full Tilt, 50 dolarów, PokerStars, darmowe bonusy.
Online poker - bonus - titan - poker omaha holdem - darmowy - omaha - freeroll - party - pkr - online game $50.
Pierwszej karty są darmowe zestawienie bonusów na pokera w promocji bez depozytu.
Sponsor , który zawiera bonus na jedną poker room i jest to Party poker darmowe 50 dolarów dla room jest bez wkładu.
Tak jak lubisz, to są fakty i plotki poker bez depozytu bonus ale inaczej mówią full tilt texas holdem poker.
Chyba że lubisz pokera w niecodziennej innej postaci karcianej lub online, zaspamuj to więc albo odczep nie potrzebne bonusy Full poker bonus bez depozytu online w dzisiejszej randce w ciemno stawiaj na email.
Czyli sprawdź za darmo bez wkładu kasy. no deposit telefone poker call without $50 - i już zdobedziesz dwadzieścia niezależnych funtów.
Na stronie pierwszej znajdziesz większość mozliwych bonusów Full tilt $50 bez depozytu na start dla dobrych kart zielonych pokerowych.
Jak widać wszycho wypaśne mail.
At 10:45 AM, drmark said...: For many causes of erectile dysfunction, managing the underlying illness will play a significant role in improving sexual function. Though, in a few of the cases, generic viagra cialis can assist with sexual activity .Viagra works on the muscles in your penis that assist control the
blood flow. During ones youth there is often little control viagra professional over these muscles which results in ill-times erections would, as a man ages he gains
control over the muscles but that control can falter and cause the inability to obtain or maintain an erection. http://www.vanusapro.com
At 12:56 AM, affiliate program said...: Good review, thanks.
Affiliate Program. Start earning today.
At 2:42 PM, US Online Pharmacy said...: The Viagra effect might be thought of as some minor problem that affects older men. Or possibly those women who live with or date older men perhaps. However, the Viagra Effect can in fact lead to problems for the larger society. Both Instapundit and Tyler Cowen point to this piece.

Now, before I explain it, take a guess at an answer to this question. When did the last widow from the US Civil War die?
At 11:21 AM, sandra said...: Generic Viagra contains Sildenafil and it is a prescription drug used to treat erectile dysfunction. Erectile dysfunction is the inability of the penis to become rigid, or stay firm long enough to complete the sexual act.
At 10:17 AM, SundayRose said...: Propecia grows hair in about 50% of men after one year and around 66% of men after two years. Overall, around 85% of men do not lose any more hair while using Propecia.
At 12:35 PM, David said...: It is definitely easier to find out informative tidbits on the erectile dysfunction drug Viagra by inserting the keyword “Viagra” in the Google search tool bar. You can also log into theResources section of the website http://www.buy-viagra-with-us.com, and obtain comprehensive Viagra information.
At 11:58 PM, barrycarter said...: If you've been diagnosed with ED (erectile dysfunction) you can Buy Cialis online for full customer satisfaction. order cheap cialis prescription or buy tadalafil at the best prices from buy specialist pharmacy.
At 12:31 PM, US Online Pharmacy said...: Buy Generic Cialis Online For Full Customer Satisfaction. Order Cheap Cialis Prescription or Buy Tadalafil at the Best Prices from 8pills.com.
Online Pharmacy | Buy Viagra | Buy Tramadol | Buy Cialis | Buy Fioricet | Buy Ultram | Buy Soma | Buy Tamiflu | Buy Levitra
At 6:03 PM, D'r kepler said...: FDA approved mens health medication viagra is not a drug to be taken lighliy you should read all about the pros and cons regarding the medication before you buy viagra!
At 12:31 PM, fabiola said...: There's a lot of Bombay in our province. Bombay are the source of money here, for they money is their business. They're like a bank where you can borrow money from, with interest of course. They're one of the best businessman here.

buy reborn dolls
At 2:14 PM, Viagra Online said...: Hello fellas, nice post here. Can I ask you about how long time is blog?!